Express All Stars
2008-Mike Reznick
2008-Daniel Estevez
2008-Mike Azark
2008-Dan Trotta - (co-manager)
2007-Chris Fuentes
2007-Bob Schwalb
2006-Angel Estevez (Midnight Express)
2006-Daniel Estevez (Midnight Express)
2006-Bob Schwalb (Midnight Express)
2006-Mike Azark (New York Express)
2006-Mike Ferris (New York Express)
2006-Nick Iosif (New York Express)

Cy Young Award
2008-Mike Reznick-Manhattan/Bronx A

League MVP nominee
2009-Carlos Quintana
2008-Phil Clemente

League Cy Young nominee
2009-Adrian Santiago

Retired numbers
Bob Schwalb, No. 11