Hamilton Trophy - League MVP
2009-Ryan Cotcamp (Bandits)

Van Buren Trophy - Outstanding Goaltender
2009-Justin Frei (Crazy 8's)

Fillmore Trophy - Best Defenseman
2009-Joe Garnet (Dangleholics)

Pullman Trophy - Consistency In Effort
2009-Dave Venturini (Jokers)

Bill Cook Trophy - Most Points
2009-Alex Leipsic (Montauk Monsters)

All-Star Game MVP
2009-Danny Christ (Blue Stars)

Commissioner's Trophy - Empire Cup Playoff MVP
2009-Mike Chiacchia (Crazy 8's)

Division 2 Playoffs MVP
2009-Jimmy Joyce Jr (Montauk Monsters)