Next Level
| Year | Player | University | Sport |
| 1956 | Jerry Gonser | University of Michigan | Football |
| 1958 | Si Woods | Marquette | Football |
| 1965 | Al Hartman | Michigan Tech | Football |
| 1967 | Jim Griffen | Ferris State | Football |
| 1967 | Ed Gall | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 1970 | Gary Ernst | University of Michigan | Wrestling |
| 1971 | Tom Laskey | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 1972 | Bill Burd | Ferris State | Football |
| 1972 | Pete Campbell | Ferris State | Football |
| 1972 | Ike Furbush | Ferris State | Football |
| 1972 | Pat Gill | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 1972 | Scott Skinner | Hillsdale/Saginaw Valley | Football |
| 1973 | Mike Guenther | Michigan Tech | Football |
| 1974 | Joe Corona | Northwestern (Big Ten) | Football |
| 1974 | Al Kaufman | University of Wyoming | Football |
| 1976 | Steve Kendzicky | Ferris State | Football |
| 1977 | Tony Corona | Grand Valley | Football |
| 1977 | Mike McGuire | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 1977 | Greg Shafer | Ferrris State | Football |
| 1977 | Ed Toth | Alma College | Football |
| 1978 | Steve Braun | Saginaw Valley | Football |
| 1979 | John Kendzicky | Grand Valley | Basketball |
| 1979 | Matt McGuire | Ferris State | Football |
| 1979 | Chip Skinner | Bowling Green | Baseball |
| 1979 | Jeff Ward | Iowa Community College /EMU | Football |
| 1980 | Jim Phelps | Bowling Green | Football |
| 1980 | John Rolen | Ferris State | Football |
| 1981 | Brad Koch | Northwood | Football |
| 1981 | Danny Pope | Iowa Community College | Football |
| 1981 | Steve Johnson | Ferris State | Football |
| 1981 | Mark Veal | Northwood | Football |
| 1982 | Todd Gensheimer | Albion College | Football |
| 1982 | Dan Pekrul | Albion College | Football |
| 1983 | Steve Mussio | Western Michigan | Football |
| 1983 | Larry Swanson | University of Toledo | Football |
| 1984 | John Barth | West Point (Army) | Football |
| 1984 | Bill Chizmar | Alma College | Football |
| 1984 | Chris Evans | University of Pennsylvania (Ivy) | Football |
| 1985 | Mike Englehardt | Northwood | Football |
| 1985 | Alan Gordon | Ferris State | Football |
| 1985 | Brad McPherson | University of Pennsylvania (Ivy) | Football |
| 1985 | David Kendzicky | Hillsdale College | Football |
| 1985 | Mark Pearsall | Ferris State | Football |
| 1986 | Grant Fanning | Hillsdale College | Football |
| 1986 | George Bairactaris | Ferris State | Football |
| 1988 | Brian Boze | University of Michigan | Track |
| 1988 | Shaun Davis | Grand Valley | Football |
| 1989 | Branko Vulicevic | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 1990 | Tom Bolvin | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 1990 | Brad Ranson | University of Alabama | Football |
| 1990 | Robert Reeves | Saginaw Valley | Football |
| 1990 | John Salame | Western Michigan | Football |
| 1991 | Jeff Comfort | Hope College | Football |
| 1992 | Roy Palmeri | Albion College | Football |
| 1994 | Greg DeGrand | Michigan State University | Wrestling |
| 1995 | Brandon Call | Michigan State University | Football |
| 1995 | Justin Francis | Adrian College | Football |
| 1996 | Chris Baker | Michigan State University / NFL | Football |
| 1996 | Ryan Lamberson | Adrian College | Football |
| 1996 | Eddie Gall | Hope College | Football |
| 1996 | Bill Welch | Hillsdale College | Football |
| 1998 | Mike Gall | Grand Valley | Football |
| 1998 | Rusty Wilson | Duke University | Football |
| 1999 | Jeremy Bernard | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 1999 | Matt Rittenour | Military Prep / Western Michigan | Football |
| 2000 | Bobby Everett | Harvard | Football |
| 2000 | Chris Gilbert | Adrian College | Football |
| 2000 | Patrick McNutt | Utah | Football |
| 2000 | Matt Swiss | Western Michigan | Football |
| 2000 | Jason Wilkinson | Saginaw Valley | Football |
| 2001 | Ryan Conn | Harding University | Football |
| 2001 | Fank Radcliff | Hope College / EMU | Football |
| 2002 | Kevin Laidlaw | Denison University | Football |
| 2003 | Ross Conn | Harding University | Football |
| 2003 | Brendan Moss | Michigan State University | Football |
| 2003 | Paul Rodenhouse | DePauw | Baseball |
| 2003 | Kyle Schuyler | Adrian College | Football |
| 2003 | Bobby Tiernan | Grand Valley | Football/BB |
| 2004 | Nate Kissell | Kalamazoo | Football |
| 2004 | Ben Wood | Hillsdale | Football |
| 2004 | Sean Brown | Saginaw Valley State University | Football |
| 2005 | Eric Wiliams | Ferris State | Football |
| 2005 | Nick Sheridan | University of Michigan | Football |
| 2005 | Jimmy Zak | Adrian College | Football |
| 2006 | Mike Adler | Morehead State, KY | Football |
| 2006 | Vince Helmuth | University of Michigan / Miami of Ohio | Football |
| 2006 | Charlie Moeller | John Carroll, OH | Football |
| 2006 | Luke O'Brien | Benedictine College, KS | Football |
| 2007 | Kyle Brown | Northwood University | Football |
| 2007 | Brian Bennyhoff | Central Michigan | Football |
| 2007 | Sam Burchyett | Grand Valley | Football |
| 2007 | Eric Matteson | Morehead State, KY | Football |
| 2007 | John Visel | Olivet | Football |
| 2008 | Nick Moeller | Wayne State | Football |
| 2008 | Travis Owens | Trine University | Football |
| 2008 | Matt Price | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 2009 | Ian Good | Kalamazoo College | Football |
| 2009 | Cory Hermann | Alma College | Football |
| 2009 | Matt Kouba | Trine University | Football |
| 2009 | Mark Sheridan | Albion College | Football |
| 2010 | Austin McBee | Kalamazoo College | Football |
| 2010 | Mitch Osadchuk | Adrian College | Football |
| 2011 | Dylan Mulder | Eastern Michigan | Football |
| 2011 | Derek Owings | Eastern Michigan / Mercer University | Football |
| 2011 | Taybor Pepper | Michigan State University | Football |
| 2011 | Joey Wooley | Heidelberg University | Football |
| 2012 | Joey Zakrajsek | Olivet Nazarene University | Football |
| 2012 | Tyler Palka | Saginaw Valley / Gannon University | Football |
| 2012 | Casey Schukow | Hillsdale College | Football |
| 2012 | Caleb Ashby | Wheaton College | Football |
| 2012 | Gavin Olson | Alma College | Football |
| 2012 | Brian Kissane | Wittenberg University | Football |
| 2013 | Travis Alexis | Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology | Football |
| 2013 | Nic Sawyer | Saginaw Valley / Ferris State | Football |
| 2013 | Max Recknagel | Saginaw Valley State University | Football |
| 2013 | Nader El-Awar | Saginaw Valley State University | Football |
| 2013 | Brad McCormick | Eastern Michigan University | Football |
| 2013 | John Smutny | Grand Valley State University | Football |
| 2013 | Ryan Tice | University of Michigan | Football |
| 2013 | Quinton Vidaurri | Heidelburg University | Football |
| 2013 | Griffin Wooley | Heidelburg University | Football |
| 2013 | Dominic DiMelis | Kalamazoo College | Football |
| 2014 | Cam Cole | Central Michigan University | Football |
| 2014 | Chris Mercer | Valparaiso / Central Michigan | Football |
| 2014 | Tyrone Miller | University of Kansas | Football |
| 2014 | Trent Theisen | Ball State University | Baseball |
| 2014 | Grant Ellis | Grand Valley State University | Football |
| 2014 | Chris Terech | University of Michigan | Football |
| 2014 | Kevin Gross | University of Michigan | Football |
| 2015 | Josh Jackson | Virginia Tech University | Football |
| 2015 | Joey Salowich | University of Dayton | Football |
| 2015 | Jeb Palka | Michigan Tech University | Football |
| 2015 | Tyler Schzran | University of St. Francis (IL) | Football |
| 2015 | Ethan DeLand | Adrian College | Football |
| 2016 | Phil Barnett | Alma College | Football |
| 2016 | Brandon Boyd | Ohio Wesleyan University | Football |
| 2016 | Robbie Felton | Brown University | Football |
| 2016 | Connor Hibbard | Oberlin College | Football |
| 2016 | Sean O'Keefe | Western Michigan University | Baseball |
| 2016 | Tyler Plocki | University of Michigan | Football |
| 2016 | Dylan Powers | Eastern Michigan University | Wrestling |
| 2016 | Caleb Rufener | Indiana Wesleyan University | Football |
| 2016 | Zach Schwartzenberger | Toledo University | Baseball |
| 2016 | Bryce Wolma | University of Arizona | Football |
| 2016 | Jake Zambeck | Alma College | Football |
| 2017 | Zarek Bratschi | Oberlin College | Football |
| 2017 | Zach Drevno | Vanderbilt University | Football |
| 2017 | Trevor Garbo | Taylor University | Football |
| 2017 | Alex Lampman | Indiana Wesleyan University | Football |
| 2017 | Jack Loveland | Kalamazoo College | Lacrosse |
| 2017 | JDrew McGovern | Wheaton College | Football |
| 2017 | Vinnie Patteri | Eastern Michigan University | Football |
| 2017 | Emmett Turner | Johns Hopkins University | Football |
Thanks to Coach Crabtree for Keeping the History and Getting This List Started!!!
(Years Listed are for the Football Season)
